In a recent English Premier League fixture, Video Assistant Referee (VAR) decisions played a crucial role in shaping the outcomes of two significant matches. During the Liverpool vs Wolves encounter, an initially awarded penalty to Liverpool was overturned by VAR after Diogo Jota went down following a challenge from Wolves defender Emmanuel Agbadou. The referee, Simon Hooper, had initially pointed to the spot, but upon review, VAR advised referee Rob Jones to check the monitor for potential violent conduct. Ultimately, it was determined that there was no "brutality," and Jota received a yellow card for simulation.
Meanwhile, in the Aston Villa vs Chelsea match, another VAR review resulted in a significant decision. Morgan Rogers found himself in an offside position, interfering with play and acting as a blocker against Nelson Semedo, which led to a disallowed goal for Aston Villa. The VAR intervention was praised as a positive application of technology, as Howard Webb, PGMOL chief, affirmed the correctness of these decisions.
Diogo Jota's involvement in the Liverpool incident was pivotal. He went down after a sliding challenge from Emmanuel Agbadou, prompting referee Simon Hooper to award a penalty. However, the decision was short-lived as VAR intervened. Howard Webb commented on the incident, stating:
"I think many people thought this was a penalty at full speed. From the pitch level, that's certainly what the referee saw." – Howard Webb
The VAR review highlighted that Agbadou's challenge was clean, leading to the overturning of the penalty decision. Webb emphasized the significance of using VAR to correct on-field errors:
"But, of course, the VAR looks at it and can see that the defender has come past the attacker before there's any sort of contact. It's not a penalty kick and, therefore, recommended a review." – VAR
This incident marked a notable moment in Premier League history as it was the first time a referee had been sent to the screen for a red card review without producing one. David Brooks also avoided a red card during Chelsea's match against Aston Villa after a collision with defender Marc Cucurella. VAR's assessment concluded there was no violent conduct, resulting in a yellow card instead.
Howard Webb praised the VAR's involvement in both instances:
"Good use of VAR to overturn a quite clearly incorrect on-field decision." – Howard Webb
He further added that Jota's actions warranted disciplinary measures:
"Diego Jota acts in a way that's meant to deceive the referee here, simulation, and, therefore, a yellow card should have been issued." – Howard Webb
The Aston Villa vs Chelsea match also witnessed VAR's impact when Morgan Rogers' interference with play led to a disallowed goal. Rogers obstructed Nelson Semedo's path to John McGinn, causing an offside offense. Webb remarked on the incident:
"So, exactly what the VAR should do, change that pretty crucial on-field decision that was incorrect and make it right." – Howard Webb
This incident highlighted the importance of assessing all aspects during an on-field review:
"I think the officials got really focused on the need to overturn the penalty. Our advice to them will be, obviously, when they go to the screen, it's not just about overturning the on-field decision, it's looking at all aspects of it." – Howard Webb
Leave a Reply