The Green Bay Packers have sparked a significant debate within the National Football League (NFL) regarding the controversial “tush push” play. The original proposal to ban the maneuver began as a targeted strike against the Philadelphia Eagles. Now, it will grow to address a broader array of situations and be considered again at the league’s annual meeting May 20-21 in Minneapolis. This latest proposal is to make it illegal for anything to shove the runner. It aims to attract public backing from eight additional clubs to further guarantee its passage.
The “tush push” involves a player pushing a runner from behind to gain extra yards, particularly effective in short-yardage situations. This tactic has been shown to have a high success rate. Teams such as the Philadelphia Eagles have turned it into a staple, running it with almost surgical precision in high-leverage situations. That’s exactly where the competition committee’s reasoning falls apart, grounded in the notion that pushing is pushing no matter the situation or the matchup.
The NFL’s rulebook allows this on field goal blocks but not on running plays. This smart rule change would help foster standard language throughout the rulebook. It’s an incredibly important step to take, not just to better include everyone in the sport, but to address critical player safety concerns. The league office has been informed of the finer points of this proposal and supports the Packers on expanding its scope.
The competition committee’s backing for the proposal was not unanimous, reflecting a divide among coaches and managers regarding the potential ban. Most recognize the competitive advantages that will accrue to the team that manages to get the play executed perfectly.
“If it’s a competitive conversation, the Eagles just coach it better than the rest of us.” – Dave Canales
Some coaches remain wary of ending the play completely, while others emphasize its historical roots. Shane Steichen, head coach of the Indianapolis Colts, put it succinctly. He stated simply, “I’m not in favor of taking it out,” noting that the play has existed in one form or another for decades. He noted that defenders often shove from the rear on quarterback sneaks around the goal line. Or if that’s true, it means the Eagles have just highlighted a long-standing strategy even further in the spotlight.
Opponents of the ban cite player safety as one of the main reasons to halt the proposed ban. League officials, including Packers president Mark Murphy, have pointed out that the nature of the play poses a risk for catastrophic injuries, particularly amid the intense physicality of NFL games.
“Sills can speak for himself, but the angle of it and the nature and the makeup of the play really does lend itself [to injury].” – Mark Murphy
Murphy further explained those worries. He cautioned that the violent impact occurring on these plays can gravely harm athletes, particularly those situated in the middle of the play. He remarked, “The centers and the people right in the middle of it, you’ve got that much force on both sides. It is just a question; I think he is right.”
Even in the face of player safety issues, many coaches aren’t ready to give up a tactic just because it’s worked well for a few teams. Los Angeles Chargers offensive coordinator Kellen Moore witnessed first-hand how many teams have attempted to mimic the Eagles’ success. Yet they’ve had a hard time achieving lasting results in their work.
“I got Nick’s back… Other teams have tried it and haven’t had as much success. Jalen [Hurts], the offensive line of Philly, they’ve been committed to it. And so it’s an investment thing.” – Kellen Moore
Moore expressed optimism at keeping the play outside the proprietary nature of the league. He stated, “I feel very comfortable with the league keeping it,” emphasizing his belief in its strategic value.
As discussions evolve surrounding this proposal, Sean McDermott, head coach of the Buffalo Bills, underscored a collaborative approach among coaches. He reiterated that their common purpose is still what’s best for the game overall.
“All three of us are about doing what’s best for the game.” – Sean McDermott
The current controversy over the tush push is part of a much-storied clash in pro football. It focuses on competitive integrity vs. player safety. The competition committee’s planned revisions aim to unify rules regarding pushing across different scenarios while addressing safety concerns highlighted by many coaches.
As teams get ready for the next league meeting in May, everyone will be watching to see what happens with this proposal. Stakeholders from all corners of the game are hoping for a thorough analysis of player safety data and competitive impact factors related to this critical play.
“Most of [the injury data] is subjective.” – Kellen Moore
Leave a Reply