The world of sports betting in the United Kingdom is going through tumultuous times. The question of transgender women competing in women’s categories has sparked an increasingly heated culture war. On April 24, the Ultimate Pool Group (UPG), which organizes high-profile pool tournaments, declared that transgender women would not be allowed to participate in its female category. This decision is a broader trend among sports organizations in England. The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has announced an ongoing review of transgender inclusion policies.
This change follows an important ruling by the UK Supreme Court on 16 April. The court ruled that the terms “female” and “male” were intended to mean exclusively biological females and males, respectively. This is hugely significant, as the Football Association (FA) has just announced their first ever football disability strategy. From the under-13 level up, only people born female can play women’s football, a policy they plan to phase in completely by June 1, 2025.
UK Supreme Court Ruling and Its Implications
The UK Supreme Court’s ruling has unleashed a flurry of policy changes among international and national governing bodies of sport. The court pointed out that “woman” means person born as (not transitioned to) a biological woman, and “man” means person who was born a biological man. In addition to its discriminatory impacts, this ruling has compelled many organizations to reconsider their policies on transgender athletes.
The FA has clearly communicated that the Supreme Court decision requires a change to its current policies.
“The Supreme Court’s ruling on April 16 means that we will be changing our policy. Transgender women will no longer be able to play in women’s football in England, and this policy will be implemented from June 1, 2025.” – The FA
As a result, the FA’s new policy will only allow those who are biologically female to compete in competitive female football. If passed, it would be one of the most remarkable changes to the definition of gender in sports to date.
Broader Impacts Across Sports
The implications of this ruling reach far beyond the world of football. Since the beginning of 2023, the ECB has excluded transgender women from participating in the upper two divisions of elite women’s cricket. That decision has triggered a massive uproar by the sports world. Under the new guidelines, transgender women and girls can participate in tier three of domestic cricket and in recreational cricket. With ongoing talks to shift them more in line with other sporting bodies, such as the ECB, moves are afoot towards something much closer.
Since September 1, England Netball has banned transgender women from playing women’s netball. This rule protects female netball by making sure that only people born female can play in female netball, no matter their gender identity. Sports organizations are continuing to proactively reconsider their inclusion policies. This change in practice is emblematic of a rising tide, fueled in recent years by favorable legal decisions.
Current Landscape for Transgender Athletes
Importantly, it should be noted that as of the time of writing there are no registered transgender women players in Scotland. So in all of England, there are probably only around 30 transgender players actively participating at the grassroots level. In a matter of months, these policy changes will have a huge impact on the lives of these people, particularly as the FA gears toward introducing its new rules.
Rob Dorsett, Sky Sports News senior reporter, hit the nail on the head. He stressed that the decisions aren’t ideological. They’re legal.
“This is not an ideological decision from the FA.” – Rob Dorsett
He further mentioned that organizations must adhere to legal standards as they evolve, stating, “They’re not making any judgment on that, but that’s the law, and they have to follow it.”
The ECB has followed suit by making allowances for transgender women to compete at lower levels. This executive order is almost immediately due to come under serious fire, as talk of even greater restrictions begins.
Ongoing Legal Challenges
Despite these exciting strides within sports organizations, litigation is ongoing. A female to male transgender judge from Britain is now challenging the UK Government in the European Court of Human Rights over the UK’s gender identity/gender rights policies. Yet, this case may introduce even greater confusion. Sports organizations now need to more thoughtfully follow public sentiment and legal precedent or risk being on the wrong side of history.
Leave a Reply