Shaw, 30, was heavily criticized after Manchester United’s most recent match against Everton. His on-field performance raised a lot of eyebrows and sparked considerable discussion among fans and analysts alike. Shaw’s role was as the left-sided centre-back in Ruben Amorim’s back three. He was rightly criticized for his lack of urgency and intensity, at times even as Manchester United was in the process of coming back from a goal down. His non-performance fueled speculation about his contributions to the team. It questioned the strategy behind the tactical decisions taken by club management.
That’s a big question going forward as Shaw’s physical decline has been ever more apparent in recent seasons. It speaks wonders that, last season, he was only able to get through 90 minutes in a single Premier League match. By comparison, he did this just seven times all of last season. This recent regressive trend in his physical performance has greatly hampered him from making the overall impact he can and should be having on the field. He’s been a lock in any Premier League xi this season, teaming up with Matthijs De Ligt, Bruno Fernandes and Bryan Mbeumo. Now that fans and analysts have started to pay attention, the pressure further mounts as they see his growing irrelevance.
Declining Performance Metrics
A deeper statistical analysis unveils a stark decline in Shaw’s attacking production over the past five years. In fact, he’s been just a consistently decreasing output of…crosses, goal involvements and chances created. His sprints and kilometers per 90 minutes have dropped off a cliff. This trend indicates that he is failing to grow more active—and therefore more effective—in this highly impactful role.
Although he has started every game this season, detractors have claimed Shaw isn’t cut out to play as a wing-back. His last few outings have been too easy for him, devoid of the requisite physicality and intensity he must bring. These issues are extremely important for a player at his position. The drop-off from who he used to be until this year is jarring.
“You have Shaw, [Leny] Yoro and [Matthijs] De Ligt behind the ball. Shaw is getting forward more, but he’s ambling forward, let’s be clear. He’s been bugging me for the last 20 minutes. He’s ambling. You can’t do that.” – Gary Neville
This critique from former player Gary Neville underscores the frustration felt by fans and analysts alike regarding Shaw’s current form. Shaw’s tendency to “amble” forward rather than sprint into attacking positions has raised questions about his commitment and readiness to contribute effectively on the pitch.
Tactical Questions Surrounding Amorim
Just like the manager of Manchester United, Ruben Amorim is under more pressure than ever to step away from his unexpected unpredictability. The criticism surrounding Shaw’s performance cannot be separated from broader concerns about the team’s strategy. Other pundits feel Amorim’s devotion to a single style of play will stunt Shaw and other players. They contend that this inflexibility could keep Shaw from reaching his peak potential.
Jamie Carragher commented on Amorim’s approach, stating, “Ruben Amorim feels like the first manager I’ve seen who sticks with a system rather than an idea of how to play.” This insistence on a strict tactical framework can stifle players, especially those that are more effective in fluid roles.
“It’s not about losing the three points against Everton, I think it is one of those moments where people will really question the manager. He will take a lot of the blame.” – Jamie Carragher
Sunday’s 2-0 loss against Everton has certainly sharpened the narrative around Amorim’s seemingly military approach to man management and it’s effect on player showing up. Shaw isn’t the first player caught out by the ever-evolving tactical demands. When taken together, this begs the question of whether the team could benefit from a new approach to achieve their highest potential.
Fan Reactions and Future Outlook
These reactions from both fans and media tell us just how low Shaw’s performance has fallen during his tenure. Many supporters express concern that he is not living up to his potential or providing the necessary support for both defense and attack.
Gary Neville further expressed his dissatisfaction with Amorim’s tactical decisions during the match against Everton: “Bringing Dalot on over there in front of Shaw? I don’t quite see it. You have five at the back, why? Embarrassing.” This comment touches on much wider sentiments about the overall handling of the team, including if players are being used in the right ways.
As Manchester United continues on its historic run, Luke Shaw’s case is particularly notable. It offers a formidable challenge and an opportunity to flourish. The club must assess whether adjustments are needed in tactics or player positioning to reinvigorate Shaw’s contributions on the pitch.
Leave a Reply