Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen have emerged as two of the top contenders for the NFL MVP award this season. While their on-field performances have been neck-and-neck, the debate surrounding who should claim the title extends beyond mere statistics. At the heart of this discussion is the racial narrative that has long surrounded the position of quarterback in the NFL. Lamar Jackson’s rise to prominence coincides with a time when many great quarterbacks are Black, challenging age-old stereotypes and societal norms. Meanwhile, Josh Allen’s journey, marked by his unique background and past controversies, adds layers to this evolving conversation.
Black quarterbacks in the NFL have historically faced challenges tied to racial stereotypes, often being viewed as more athletic but less intelligent than their white counterparts. This bias has presented significant hurdles, influencing both their opportunities and how they are perceived. Lamar Jackson's success challenges these outdated notions, not only through his exceptional athleticism but also through his "quarterbacky" style of play, which combines strategic thinking and precision passing. In doing so, Jackson represents a broader movement against stereotypes and discrimination in sports.
The struggle of Black quarterbacks in the NFL is not new. Warren Moon, for instance, was the MVP of the Rose Bowl in 1977 but went uninvited to the NFL Combine, forcing him to begin his professional career in the Canadian Football League (CFL). Moon's experience underscores the systemic barriers that Black athletes have faced for decades. A 2015 study further highlighted these challenges, revealing that Black quarterbacks were twice as likely to be benched after subpar performances compared to their white counterparts.
The ongoing debate over the NFL MVP award this season is emblematic of these deeper issues. While Lamar Jackson's emergence highlights progress, it also brings racial baggage to the forefront of sports discussions. Meanwhile, Josh Allen's candidacy raises questions about adversity and privilege. Allen's path to stardom is distinct from Jackson's; he did not have superstar parents or a privileged upbringing. His rise can be seen as a defiance of the "DEI" narrative, often associated with players who overcome adversity.
Josh Allen's on-field skillset has won him admiration beyond just Bills fans and football enthusiasts. However, his journey has not been without controversy. Past tweets, where Allen used the N-word while quoting rap lyrics, resurfaced, sparking criticism. Although Allen has apologized for these comments, noting that they do not reflect his current values, some argue that his apology was insufficient to quell the noise surrounding his past remarks.
The idea of adversity in sports transcends individual experiences and touches on broader societal issues. For Lamar Jackson, achieving success as a Black quarterback involves navigating a landscape that has historically undervalued intellect in favor of athleticism. Conversely, Josh Allen's narrative challenges perceptions about privilege and success.
“In the history of football, I’ve never really played against another quarterback,” said Josh Allen.
This statement reflects the unique nature of the rivalry between Allen and Jackson. Their matchup on Sunday is not just a contest of skills but also a celebration of individual achievements and a testament to the progress made by Black quarterbacks in the NFL.
As discussions continue about who deserves the MVP award more—Jackson or Allen—it becomes clear that this debate is about more than just football. It encapsulates themes of race, privilege, and redemption. The narratives surrounding both players offer insights into how society views success and adversity.
Leave a Reply