Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane certainly isn’t mincing words. He has fervently condemned the condition in which the team has been playing in recent months under manager Ruben Amorim. During that discussion on how the team was performing, Keane made his feelings clear. He insists that their rivals Manchester United are currently “not good enough” and don’t have the mentality required to be competitive in the league. His comments help put recent performances into context. All this has failed to live up to the billing of one of football’s biggest clubs.
Keane was merciless in his attack on the side’s lack of a winning mindset. In fact, he claimed that he had never really had a conversation with his players about “philosophy” before. It became clear that, rather than focusing on possession for possession’s sake, he wanted results and he wanted to see real improvements on the pitch. It is his view that deep and sweeping change is needed immediately if the club ever hopes to get back to being a competitive organization.
Performance Criticism
The former City and England playmaker was extremely harsh on what he viewed as a limited attacking threat from Manchester United. He complained the current strikers are not good enough for a team competing for top honors. Keane continued, “I’ve been to a couple of live games recently. This is one of his works that when I first encountered it, I was knocking over my cups of tea in delight. Now they were all clean and beautiful – but never going to actually score. No goals again today.” This observation only serves to highlight his frustration as the team continues to flounder and misfire in front of goal.
Additionally, he spoke about the players’ mindsets after games, seeming satisfied with bad performances. “I see the United team today: they’re all applauding and they’re being interviewed and they said, ‘draw is not too bad.’ A draw gets you nowhere fast! It was the same against Arsenal a few weeks ago,” he moaned. Keane’s fury is no less subtle as he berates the players’ lack of desire to win.
He didn’t stop with the forwards – he spoke out about the defensive corps being shaky at best. He pointedly said that a bunch of the players just aren’t “good enough” to play for Manchester United.
Need for Changes
Keane pushed for urgent reforms. Second, he is right that Manchester United need to sign a minimum of five new players to make their next season dreams come true. He said, “The manager is going to go down the line … That’s the risk he is accepting.” He was doubtful that Amorim could get the current squad back on track.
He went on to elaborate that although Amorim may have his “idea” and “philosophy”, it needs to be expressed in terms of winning football games first. “That’s fine. But I’m very much into the philosophy of winning football matches. I really like that philosophy,” said Ten Hag, an indication of a very basic standard from a manager of Manchester United’s history.
What Keane’s comments go beyond plain frustration for is a demand to be better, from both his leadership and his supporters—including management. He’s said that big changes are needed in the soon-to-open summer transfer window. Without these simple but essential changes, Manchester United will be unable to compete at the top end of the league.
Future Prospects
Looking ahead, Keane remains doubtful about United’s chances of breaking into the top six next season unless substantial changes are implemented. “I’d like to be proven wrong and United are in the top five or six next season and would take it all back, but I don’t see it,” he articulated, highlighting his lack of confidence in the current trajectory.
Defensive issues were laid bare against Manchester City and similar teams in the Premier League. These issues stem from the fact that Amorim can’t reach the talent he needs. This erosion of quality, in Keane’s estimation, dramatically undermines their overall contention.
Leave a Reply