The final day action this weekend in the Scottish premiership was full of drama. A number of controversial refereeing decisions were exposed. It is VAR that was in the spotlight. John Beaton during Livingston’s match against Aberdeen last season in which Beaton made a couple of notable, game-changing decisions. He gave a penalty for a handball and he disallowed a Rangers goal. The discussions surrounding these incidents featured insights from ex-Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher and former footballer Jay Bothroyd on the Sky Sports show Ref Watch.
In the course of that match, Beaton came under intense pressure, when he was told to check on a possible handball by VAR. After checking the pitch-side monitor, he decided to award a penalty, a decision that would draw outrage from fans and pundits everywhere. The game was already an electric affair, with Hearts up 1-0. The tension was heightened when Rangers had a goal disallowed for an apparent foul on their keeper.
Key Incidents Under Review
The weekend’s matches provided ample material for debate, as Beaton’s decisions were put under the microscope. One of the unexpected highlights came during Hearts’ match, when they were awarded a penalty. This followed US defender Harry Milne being floored by Mohamed Diomande. Even during the match, the complexity of the challenge and whether it deserved to be a penalty kick was in question.
Referees are under extreme pressure when making a split-second decision. These controversial moves can make all the difference in the outcome of a match.
“Tough call, I think. I’m in two minds about this.” – Dermot Gallagher
It was a critical match moment for Yan Dhanda. His caution came on a contested red card after a hard two-footed tackle on Lukas Fadinger. This decision sparked outrage, with Bothroyd arguing that the punishment was disproportionate.
“Was there contact there? It didn’t look like it to me. If there is, it is the slightest bit of contact.” – Jay Bothroyd
Furthermore, Rangers’ disallowed goal intensified the debate over Beaton’s officiating. The foul on the keeper that caused the disallowance turned heads all across fans and pundits. As important as VAR can be, Gallagher mentioned that the on-field referee’s decision is often times the heaviest in weight.
Controversial Red Card and Disallowed Goal
This emotional reaction to a critical decision points to the intricate layers that must be navigated by referees during highly pressed matches.
“I would have got a red card for arguing with the referee. It is so harsh.” – Jay Bothroyd
As technology plays a bigger role in football officiating, the arguments for and against VAR rage on. Catch up on the VAR Review show which was first broadcast on Sky Sports here. It looked at different instances that affected the clubs of Rangers, Hearts, Kilmarnock, Celtic, Hibernian, Dundee United, Dundee and Motherwell. The current concern over officials’ calls highlights the importance of having clear rules and consistent enforcement.
“You can’t tell from one angle whether he’s clipped him. The other angle? Is there contact? But the fact the referee gave it on-field means VAR will stick with it.” – Dermot Gallagher
Gallagher observed that Beaton’s controversial decision to award a penalty for handball initiated an important discussion.
VAR and Its Impact on Decision Making
Fans and analysts are already busy dissecting these important moments. Whatever the motives of the SBFA, it’s certain that refereeing decisions will continue to be a contentious issue in Scottish football.
Gallagher pointed out that Beaton’s decision to award a penalty for handball sparked debate.
“That is handball. It is not seen by the referee.” – Dermot Gallagher
He further elaborated on his thoughts regarding the penalty decision:
“It’s extremely harsh. I thought when the referee was sent to the monitor, he wouldn’t give it.” – Dermot Gallagher
As fans and analysts dissect these crucial moments, it is clear that refereeing decisions will remain a hot topic in Scottish football.
Leave a Reply