British media coverage of the introduction of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology to the Premier League this season is underscoring the controversy. A recent handball incident involving Newcastle United goalkeeper Nick Pope and Coventry City forward Viktor Gyokeres has intensified that discussion. VAR then overturned the penalty awarded from an initial challenge by Pope on Gyokeres during the game. This decision led to a furious debate among football experts over the usefulness, accuracy and implementation of the technology.
Even former referee Howard Webb backed the VAR decision to overturn the penalty, praising it as the correct call. The incident has reignited debates surrounding consistency in officiating and the overall impact of VAR on the excitement of the game. Even former player Paul Merson was vocal about his VAR distaste, stating that this isn’t taking away from the beautiful game.
The Incident at Newcastle
The third goal was the most remarkable moment that started to draw national attention. Nick Pope’s challenge on Viktor Gyokeres forced the first penalty to be given. After a review by VAR, match officials reversed the call on the field. Webb himself stated on this decision, doubling down on VAR’s intervention being a good call.
Whether a penalty should have been awarded continues to be debated fiercely today. This has led some critics to claim Pope was guilty of having made minimal contact with the ball. Nevertheless, they argue that he in the end erased Gyokeres, indicating the challenge’s nature and what that means for penalty decisions. This incident hasn’t been the only challenge, as similar issues have fueled discussion all season long.
“I don’t know what they are watching.” – Paul Merson
Merson’s anger towards VAR has been shared by millions across the global football community. He feels each of those decisions takes something away from the experience and feel of the game. This goes beyond VAR simply ruining match-day experiences.
The Broader Impact of VAR
VAR has been under fire for how it’s been applied in several Premier League games this season. Each key decision, implemented or anticipated, was walked through using the system. This extended to the video review of Eberechi Eze’s goal for Crystal Palace against Chelsea, which Darren England reviewed on a pitchside monitor. In particular, critics point out that for all of VAR’s pursuit of accuracy, it still results in players receiving different rulings on similar incidents.
Merson lamented how VAR’s constant interruptions suck the excitement out of a match. As our Ian Plenderleith pointed out, fans can’t even celebrate goals anymore without the dread of a potential VAR review hanging above it.
“You can’t celebrate a goal anymore with VAR. There’s no point.” – Paul Merson
He goes on to describe how re-justifying goals every day is a heavy lift for players and fans alike. This diversion contributes to a dispiriting atmosphere that saps the joy that is the essence of competitive sports.
Suggestions for Improvement
Merson suggested that introducing ex-players who understand the game better could improve VAR’s decision-making. He thinks their perspectives might provide some much-needed context to referees today. This proposal is based on his belief that officiating conversations today have lost key aspects of the game.
“It’s priceless knowledge and it is something the referees haven’t got. Their conversations on the pitch show you that.” – Paul Merson
Webb underscored the importance of further incorporation of football experience into officiating. He expressed hope for a day when referees would confidently uphold their decisions despite VAR reviews, thus maintaining their authority on the pitch.
“Put someone like that with VAR and they will give you that football context.” – Howard Webb
And the current VAR flap out there highlights its controversial presence in the world of football today. These and other recent incidents have ignited a firestorm of debate seeking to punish and/or penalize foul play. Though technology aims to improve the quality of officiating, it undermines the spirit of the game at the same time.
Leave a Reply