In a significant development, Manchester City has claimed victory in a legal challenge against the Premier League regarding the legality of the previous Associated Party Transactions (APT) rules. An independent panel has declared these rules void and unenforceable, marking a pivotal moment in a broader dispute involving over 100 alleged breaches of financial rules dating back to 2009. This decision arrives amidst ongoing contention over the Premier League's Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) and the recently introduced APT regulations.
The Premier League initially implemented the APT rules in December 2021 following the Saudi takeover of Newcastle United. These rules aimed to ensure that commercial deals with companies linked to clubs' ownership were conducted at fair market value. However, Manchester City contested this framework after being blocked from proceeding with new agreements involving Etihad Airways and First Abu Dhabi Bank. The Premier League argued that these deals would have violated the PSR.
Despite the tribunal's decision to invalidate the previous APT rules, the Premier League maintains that this judgment does not undermine the current regulations. The league insists that clubs must continue to adhere to the existing APT rules while awaiting further legal clarification. In November 2024, clubs voted to approve revisions to the APT rules, addressing three areas previously deemed unlawful by the tribunal.
"The tribunal's decision has found that the three narrow aspects of the old APT rules, previously found to be unlawful, cannot be separated from the rest of the previous rules as a matter of law."
- The Premier League
The new APT rules seek to prevent wealthier clubs from inflating deal values to allocate more funds towards player acquisitions and remain compliant with PSR. Manchester City is also challenging the legality of these updated regulations, hoping for a favorable ruling for the third time. The club argues that the amendments made by the Premier League in November should not have been necessary if the original rules had not been unlawfully imposed.
While the tribunal's decision marks a legal victory for Manchester City, its ultimate benefit hinges on whether the current APT rules are deemed lawful. This uncertainty adds another layer of complexity to an already intricate financial landscape within English football. The outcome of this ongoing legal battle could potentially reshape how clubs negotiate and manage commercial partnerships moving forward.
The Premier League's stance underscores its commitment to safeguarding financial fairness and sustainability across its member clubs. Despite setbacks, the league remains resolute in ensuring that its regulations serve their intended purpose. Meanwhile, clubs continue to navigate these evolving financial guidelines as they seek clarity on what lies ahead.
Leave a Reply